meta.codidact.com

General Q&A about the Codidact instance hosted at codidact.com or the software that runs it.

Understanding how posts were possibly received by the community --- network wide

I would always claim that anonymous upvoting and downvoting are a crappy quality assurance method causing more harm than good in the long run due to unbased (or well based) accumulated hostility and would generally not even use it but if it is the only method to get communal feedback on a user's posts I would reluctantly use it.

It's a bit frustrating for me to check every Codidact website to learn how a given post of mine (or of another user) was received by the community. I'd prefer to have visit some single webpage that will show two tables per network website (one for questions and one for answers) with any post I have published in any website in the network (probably it will include a pager in case there are too many posts per table); From there, to easily know how many upvotes and upvotes each post got (if at all) and on the way, to know what is my "reputation points number" on the relevant network website.

Review Answer

1 answer

Last answer: Monica Cellio about 18 hours ago

0

0

Giving question feedback in private - a moderating system to reduce conflicts

I would always claim that anonymous upvoting and downvoting are a crappy quality assurance method causing more harm than good in the long run due to unbased (or well based) accumulated hostility and would generally not even use it but if it is the only method to get communal feedback on a user's posts I would reluctantly use it.

It's a bit frustrating for me to check every Codidact website to learn how a given post of mine (or of another user) was received by the community. I'd prefer to have visit some single webpage that will show two tables per network website (one for questions and one for answers) with any post I have published in any website in the network (probably it will include a pager in case there are too many posts per table); From there, to easily know how many upvotes and upvotes each post got (if at all) and on the way, to know what is my "reputation points number" on the relevant network website.

Review Answers

4 answers

Last comment: FoggyFinder 6 days ago

7

1

Cancelation prompt is unintuitive

I would always claim that anonymous upvoting and downvoting are a crappy quality assurance method causing more harm than good in the long run due to unbased (or well based) accumulated hostility and would generally not even use it but if it is the only method to get communal feedback on a user's posts I would reluctantly use it.

It's a bit frustrating for me to check every Codidact website to learn how a given post of mine (or of another user) was received by the community. I'd prefer to have visit some single webpage that will show two tables per network website (one for questions and one for answers) with any post I have published in any website in the network (probably it will include a pager in case there are too many posts per table); From there, to easily know how many upvotes and upvotes each post got (if at all) and on the way, to know what is my "reputation points number" on the relevant network website.

Review Answer

1 answer

Last comment: Monica Cellio 2 months ago

11

0

Inconsistant picture sizes in users list

I would always claim that anonymous upvoting and downvoting are a crappy quality assurance method causing more harm than good in the long run due to unbased (or well based) accumulated hostility and would generally not even use it but if it is the only method to get communal feedback on a user's posts I would reluctantly use it.

It's a bit frustrating for me to check every Codidact website to learn how a given post of mine (or of another user) was received by the community. I'd prefer to have visit some single webpage that will show two tables per network website (one for questions and one for answers) with any post I have published in any website in the network (probably it will include a pager in case there are too many posts per table); From there, to easily know how many upvotes and upvotes each post got (if at all) and on the way, to know what is my "reputation points number" on the relevant network website.

Answer now

0 answers

Last comment: Olin Lathrop 2 months ago

5

0

Advertise Codidact.com on your vehicle?

I would always claim that anonymous upvoting and downvoting are a crappy quality assurance method causing more harm than good in the long run due to unbased (or well based) accumulated hostility and would generally not even use it but if it is the only method to get communal feedback on a user's posts I would reluctantly use it.

It's a bit frustrating for me to check every Codidact website to learn how a given post of mine (or of another user) was received by the community. I'd prefer to have visit some single webpage that will show two tables per network website (one for questions and one for answers) with any post I have published in any website in the network (probably it will include a pager in case there are too many posts per table); From there, to easily know how many upvotes and upvotes each post got (if at all) and on the way, to know what is my "reputation points number" on the relevant network website.

Review Answer

1 answer

Last comment: Lundin 2 months ago

0

0

Show question when editing answer.

I would always claim that anonymous upvoting and downvoting are a crappy quality assurance method causing more harm than good in the long run due to unbased (or well based) accumulated hostility and would generally not even use it but if it is the only method to get communal feedback on a user's posts I would reluctantly use it.

It's a bit frustrating for me to check every Codidact website to learn how a given post of mine (or of another user) was received by the community. I'd prefer to have visit some single webpage that will show two tables per network website (one for questions and one for answers) with any post I have published in any website in the network (probably it will include a pager in case there are too many posts per table); From there, to easily know how many upvotes and upvotes each post got (if at all) and on the way, to know what is my "reputation points number" on the relevant network website.

Answer now

0 answers

Last comment: celtschk 2 months ago

6

0

closure-as-duplicate post notice is inaccurate

I would always claim that anonymous upvoting and downvoting are a crappy quality assurance method causing more harm than good in the long run due to unbased (or well based) accumulated hostility and would generally not even use it but if it is the only method to get communal feedback on a user's posts I would reluctantly use it.

It's a bit frustrating for me to check every Codidact website to learn how a given post of mine (or of another user) was received by the community. I'd prefer to have visit some single webpage that will show two tables per network website (one for questions and one for answers) with any post I have published in any website in the network (probably it will include a pager in case there are too many posts per table); From there, to easily know how many upvotes and upvotes each post got (if at all) and on the way, to know what is my "reputation points number" on the relevant network website.

Review Answers

2 answers

Last comment: FoggyFinder 2 months ago

4

0

What are the pros and cons of gamifying Codidact.org?

I would always claim that anonymous upvoting and downvoting are a crappy quality assurance method causing more harm than good in the long run due to unbased (or well based) accumulated hostility and would generally not even use it but if it is the only method to get communal feedback on a user's posts I would reluctantly use it.

It's a bit frustrating for me to check every Codidact website to learn how a given post of mine (or of another user) was received by the community. I'd prefer to have visit some single webpage that will show two tables per network website (one for questions and one for answers) with any post I have published in any website in the network (probably it will include a pager in case there are too many posts per table); From there, to easily know how many upvotes and upvotes each post got (if at all) and on the way, to know what is my "reputation points number" on the relevant network website.

Review Answers

2 answers

Last comment: System 1 month ago

4

11